Why Our Lives Are So Cluttered

Have you gone through several iterations of de-cluttering, only to feel like you really didn’t make much progress? The likely reason for this is that our lives are filled with clutter, rather than us just having a few areas of clutter.

I realized this as I began reading Your Money or Your Life: 9 Steps to Transforming Your Relationship with Money a couple of nights ago. Pretty early in the book, the authors talk about something called the fulfillment curve, which looks like this:

Cluttered lives

We start out in life unfulfilled, with nothing, and we start acquiring stuff. At some point, we peak (the top of the curve) when we have enough. That’s the magic thing that we’re always looking for: enough.

But, of course we don’t stop acquiring. We enter the zone when we begin having more than enough, and therefore begin accumulating clutter. And most of us accumulate it all of our lives. The sad thing is, we don’t just have more stuff than we need, we now have stuff we don’t need that demands our attention in some way: we have to maintain it, fix it, continue to make payments on it, store it, …

So we start becoming less fulfilled instead of more so.

Take a simple example of my guitars. I have four of them, all very nice guitars, including two that I inherited from my Dad, one that was autographed by the legendary Buster B Jones a few weeks before he died (the last thing he autographed), and one that has been with me for over 30 years. And I have not played any of them in three months. I now have to restring every one of them, and the one that is 30 years old needs new frets. And then I’ll play with them for a few days, then three of them will just set around for months.

It actually gives me anxiety thinking about how those guitars are being wasted, three of them anyway. I don’t need all four. But, I keep them nonetheless.

Then there are the 100′s of books, some going back to my college days of over 30 years ago. And my late wife’s jewelry: enough to start a store. Closets full of clothes I haven’t worn in a long while, and so on.

I bet you have similar examples.

And, when you stop and think about, the clutter goes beyond purchases: we also clutter our lives with activities that are of no real value to us.

So, what do we do? We can do some de-cluttering. It seems to me, though, that what we most need to work on is our constant desire to fill our lives with more “stuff,” be that unnecessary purchases or activities that are of no value. I don’t have any advice for you on how to do that, at least not at this time. For now I can only present it as something we should be aware of and work on to the extent that we can.

[Picture Source: New Road Map to Financial Integrity]


 

This entry was posted in Insights and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • John

    In my opinion, there is another mechanism involved: Endowment Effect (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endowment_effect) . We have the irrational bias to value things we own more than they should be.

    • http://www.keenerliving.com/ Bruce Keener

      Good point, John. We have evolved to have so many biases and irrationalities that I sometimes wonder how we made it “out of the caves.”

      Thanks for the comment.

  • John

    Based on what I read, most of our irrational biases help us most of the time because they allow us to short-circuit many decision-makings without tapping into the resource-hungry logical side of the brain.

    • http://www.keenerliving.com/ Bruce Keener

      Another good point, John. I think it’s still somewhat disputed, though. Some psychologists would agree, some would not.

      It’s clear that the irrationalities had their benefits during the time we were evolving, in that they helped us make many decisions quickly, when our lives may well have been in danger. In these times, though, when so many of our decisions are complex, they could be working against us.

      I think the topic makes for an interesting debate, one that I am not really qualified to participate in, but it sure is an interesting subject.

      Thanks again for a great comment. Time for me to hit the sack.

      Best wishes

  • Thomas R. Hall

    I’m glad you’re enjoying “Your Money or Your Life”, Bruce. It’s an excellent book that I’m actually getting ready to re-read. Love when you bring good books to people’s attention.

    • http://www.keenerliving.com/ Bruce Keener

      I know you will enjoy the re-read, Thomas … it’s a well-written book with some different than the norm insights.

  • http://ruudhein.com Ruud Hein

    A lot of stuff I can do without and ever since a life changing event 2 years ago I’ve been simplifying my life. Not to say I’m wandering around in empty spaces…

    Easiest and most effective measure? Never buy anything over $x today. I love gadgets and new ‘puter stuff … but I won’t buy it today. Often a week later the need has gone :)

    As a reward I get to feel so good about making stuff *last* vs “making do”. Picking up my 2005 laptop has me see my old friend. Sticking to the camera I like has meant I got to know it, love it and use it to the max.

    The things that matter, the stuff that matters, I try to replicate digitally at the moment. I’m well aware, as are you, that you can’t hold on to people, the past, life, but it gives me … a goal, a purpose :)

    Thanks for the post, Bruce.

    • http://www.keenerliving.com/ Bruce Keener

      Thank you for the comment, Ruud. Good technique for avoiding the urge-to-buy. That’s an area I really have to work on.

  • http://ariwriter.com Ari Herzog

    I used to tote 350+ CDs in three banana boxes from apartment to apartment. I set them up alphabetically, poked through the collection now and then, then packed them up and moved on.

    About four years ago, I made two piles for selling to used CD stores and for giving away for free to interested collectors. I also imported a large number of the CDs onto iTunes for use on a then-purchased iPod.

    Fast forward, and I own zero CDs; and I rarely listen to iTunes any more. The iPod collects dust.

    Point being, Bruce, you should get rid of your clutter. Don’t keep. Sell, toss, or give away to share the love.

    • http://www.keenerliving.com/ Bruce Keener

      Hi Ari,
      Thanks for sharing your own experience here. You are right that I need to let go of a lot of stuff. Maybe just donate a ton of books for starters. Anyway, thanks for the comment.